Injection in buttocks: 1" vs. 1 1/2" needle

I am a new graduate who has yet a lot to learn but I am a bit confused about giving injections in the buttocks. One of the nurses who trained me told me to use a 1 inch needle when you give Depo-Provera, Phenergan, Kenalog and B12 injections. The only time I use the 1 and 1/2 inch needle is when I give Depo-Testoserone and Rocephin.
Last week I had to give a Phenergan injection to a dehydrated patient who came into our clinic for an office visit (I work in Family Practice). I started her IV and once she was settled I gave her anti-nausea medication in her bottom using a 1" needle. Another nurse (20 year verteran) who was working with me told I should have used a 1 and half inch needle instead of a one inch needle. :uhoh21:Then yet another nurse (30+) told me I should have given injection in the arm with 1 inch. Who is right? Please help!
In a small person with little padding for an IM injection I'd opt for a 1 inch needle (elderly, child). In those with extra padding, I'd go for 1 1/2 inch. If there is more tissue, you have to make sure you get through it into the muscle, so a bigger person will need a longer needle.In the deltoid muscle I think that 1 inch is probably sufficient. It all depends on where you're sticking. As to giving phenergan in the arm....I don't think I'd opt for that as phenergan has some nasty side effects. But maybe I'm wrong. I don't give shots all that often, and I wouldn't argue with a nurse who's been a nurse for 30 years

Quote from tencatIn a small person with little padding for an IM injection I'd opt for a 1 inch needle (elderly, child). In those with extra padding, I'd go for 1 1/2 inch. If there is more tissue, you have to make sure you get through it into the muscle, so a bigger person will need a longer needle.

I, too, am one who needs a longer needle, especially if I'm getting shot in the rear-end

I believe that Promethazine is supposed to be given deep in a sturdy muscle (your long needle). Your supposed to avoid SC due to pot. tissue damage.

Quote from azilliRNLast week I had to give a Phenergan injection to a dehydrated patient who came into our clinic for an office visit (I work in Family Practice). I started her IV and once she was settled I gave her anti-nausea medication in her bottom using a 1" needle. Another nurse (20 year verteran) who was working with me told I should have used a 1 and half inch needle instead of a one inch needle. :uhoh21:Then yet another nurse (30+) told me I should have given injection in the arm with 1 inch. Who is right? Please help!

Quote from leslie :-Dphenergan, i'd want deep muscle so deltoid would be out.however, deltoid should be absolutely fine with 1" needle.as tencat said, kids and (frail) elderly should be fine with 1" as well, with 1.5" being reserved for those with an 'abundance" of adipose tissue.bottom line is, it's supposed to be a nsg judgment re length and site.leslie

Yes to all, you have to use your eyes and common sense, thinner patients, 1 inch; medium to heavier patients 1-1/2 inch. Maybe even really obese, 2 inch (do they make them?)

Agree with all of the above advice re: site and decision making re: length of needle. My question is -- why didn't you just give the phenergan IV if you had to put one in (assumably for fluids?) Is this not allowed in a clinic setting?

Quote from CNL2BAgree with all of the above advice re: site and decision making re: length of needle. My question is -- why didn't you just give the phenergan IV if you had to put one in (assumably for fluids?) Is this not allowed in a clinic setting?

Quote from Asystole RNPhenergan is a vesicant, many facilities are moving towards administering it through central lines only. It is very harsh on veins and can cause tissue damage/necrosis, to be honest I have never seen it given IM, would imagine it to be very painful.P.S. Personally I never give gluteal injections. There are easier, safer, less painful, more dignified places to give injections.

Here you go. Straight from the FDAhttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=79lJuEM5FnQIf you have ever had it IV you will NEVER forget it. I have a sclerosed vein in my right arm that reminds me daily.

Wow. Those were some icky pictures. I guess I'm not sure how IM would be any better --- to have THAT directly into muscle? I don't remember the last time I gave phenergan...it's definitely been awhile, and was likely central as most of my patients where I work have central lines. Our docs seem to prefer other drugs for nausea (perhaps for this reason?)